A question that I get asked more & more about is, “Does ISR swimming work?”
I figured I would give my OPINION, coming from an instructors point of view on the topic.
This is not a post to bash ISR swim instructors.
From An Instructors Point Of View!
I never cared to learn about ISR (Infant Swimming Resource) until later in life.
Since I was 17, I had been teaching swimming but had not seen ISR until YouTube recommended it.
After watching videos of babies rolling over, back floating, taking a breath and giving parents time to rescue them, It definitely was intriguing.
I must say that it is what you want your child to do if you’re not around & they fell in the pool.
My wife & I looked into it more in hopes to offer another style of lessons just in case someone really wanted it. Ultimately we decided not to offer ISR aka (Infante Self Rescue) style.
Why ISR swim instruction does NOT work in my opinion after learning some facts!
ISR swim instruction is ineffective because it only focuses on teaching children to submerge & float. Instead of teaching them the proper stroke technique & how to swim.
The way in which ISR is introduced is very shocking to a child’s system that is not familiar with the water. There is no slow intro to help a child understand the water before entering.
ISR heavily relies on repetition, which might not be effective for some children & can cause frustration and exhaustion.
ISR does not include drills or stroke technique, which can hinder a swimmer’s progress & growth.
Lastly, ISR does not offer any type of progress tracking. This makes it challenging for instructors to measure if their students are improving or not.
In Conclusion:
For 18+ years, I have taught everyone from babies to adults.
This style of instruction can be shocking for a child who is not used to the water. It can be especially difficult for a child who is scared and needs to be eased into the water.
I don’t want to criticize this teaching style since it has worked for many people, but I prefer to have a good relationship with my students and parents.